📦This is an archived page▼
Archived:pending
Original URL:https://old.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians
Domain:old.reddit.com
Archive ID:#667
jump to content
my subreddits
edit subscriptions
  • home
  • -popular
  • -all
  • -users
 | 
     | 
    • AskReddit
    • -pics
    • -funny
    • -movies
    • -worldnews
    • -news
    • -todayilearned
    • -nottheonion
    • -explainlikeimfive
    • -mildlyinteresting
    • -DIY
    • -videos
    • -OldSchoolCool
    • -europe
    • -TwoXChromosomes
    • -tifu
    • -Music
    • -books
    • -LifeProTips
    • -dataisbeautiful
    • -aww
    • -science
    • -space
    • -Showerthoughts
    • -askscience
    • -Jokes
    • -Art
    • -IAmA
    • -Futurology
    • -sports
    • -UpliftingNews
    • -food
    • -nosleep
    • -creepy
    • -history
    • -gifs
    • -InternetIsBeautiful
    • -GetMotivated
    • -gadgets
    • -announcements
    • -de_IAmA
    • -WritingPrompts
    • -philosophy
    • -Documentaries
    • -Bundesliga
    • -EarthPorn
    • -photoshopbattles
    • -listentothis
    • -blog
    edit »
    AskHistorians AskHistorians
    • hot
    • new
    • rising
    • controversial
    • top
    • wiki
    )|messages|notifications|chat messages|
    • preferences
    |
    logout
    [-]

    use the following search parameters to narrow your results:

    subreddit:subreddit
    find submissions in "subreddit"
    author:username
    find submissions by "username"
    site:example.com
    find submissions from "example.com"
    url:text
    search for "text" in url
    selftext:text
    search for "text" in self post contents
    self:yes (or self:no)
    include (or exclude) self posts
    nsfw:yes (or nsfw:no)
    include (or exclude) results marked as NSFW

    e.g. subreddit:aww site:imgur.com dog

    see the search faq for details.

    advanced search: by author, subreddit...

    Ask a question

    AskHistorians

    joinleave
    [redacted]
    1. This Week's Theme is Love

    New to /r/AskHistorians? Please read our subreddit rules and FAQ before posting!

    Apply for Flair

    • Upvote informative, well sourced answers
    • Downvote and Report comments that are unhelpful or grossly off-topic

    The Rules, in Brief

    1. Be Nice: No Racism, Bigotry, or Offensive Behavior.
    2. Nothing Less Than 20 Years Old, and Don't Soapbox.
    3. Questions should be clear and specific in what they ask, and should be able to get detailed answers from historians whose expertise is likely to be in particular times and places.
    4. Write Original, In-Depth and Comprehensive Answers, Using Good Historical Practices.
    5. Provide Primary and Secondary Sources If Asked. No Tertiary Sources Like Wikipedia.
    6. Serious On-Topic Comments Only: No Jokes, Anecdotes, Clutter, or other Digressions.
    7. Report Comments That Break Reddiquette or the Subreddit Rules.
    8. Please Read and Understand the Rules Before Contributing.

    Resources

    • Subreddit rules
    • Rules Roundtable disussions
    • Popular questions (FAQ)
    • Monthly Award Winners
    • The AskHistorians Podcast
    • Books and Resources list
    • List of flaired users
    • Flaired User Profiles
    • The AskHistorians Browser Extension
    • Research Policy
    • More
    • Follow Us on Bluesky

    Flair

    Our flaired users have detailed knowledge of their historical specialty and a proven record of excellent contributions to /r/AskHistorians.

    Flair categories
    • African History
    • North American History
    • Middle and South American History
    • Asian History
    • European History
    • Middle Eastern History
    • Oceanic History
    • Art History
    • History of Religion and Philosophy
    • Military History
    • History of Science and Technology
    • Archaeology
    • Quality Contributor
    • Moderator

    To nominate someone else as a Quality Contributor, message the mods.

    Upcoming Events

    Please Subscribe to our Google Calendar for Upcoming AMAs and Events

    March 3 | AMA with Dr. Jake Newsome, historian of LGBTQ+ people during the Nazi regime

    April 14 | AMA with Gabe Henry, author of the upcoming book Enough Is Enuf: Our Failed Attempts to Make English Easier to Spell

    Previous AMAs | Previous Roundtables

    Features

    Feature posts are posted weekly. The current rotation is:

    • Monday Methods (upcoming themes)
    • Tuesday Trivia (upcoming themes)
    • Short Answers to Simple Questions
    • Thursday Reading and Research
    • Friday Free-for-All
    • Saturday Showcase
    • Sunday Digest
    • AskHistorians Podcast (biweekly)
    • Floating Features
    • Great Questions!
    • Previous features

    Related subreddits

    • /r/AskScience
    • /r/AskSocialScience
    • /r/AskAnthropology
    • /r/AskAcademia
    • /r/CredibleDefense
    • /r/History
    • /r/badhistory
    • /r/HistoryWhatIf
    • /r/WWI
    • More

    Follow us on social media

    • @askhistorians on BlueSky
    • AskHistorians on Tumblr
    • AskHistorians on Goodreads
    created by ArtrwFoundera community for 14 years
    Create your own subreddit
    ...because you hate freedom.
    ...for your favorite hobby.

    MODERATORS

    • message the mods
    • BernarditoModerator | Modern Guerrilla | Counterinsurgency
    • DaeresModerator | Ancient Greece | Ancient Near East
    • AutoModerator
    • Georgy_K_ZhukovModerator | Dueling | Modern Warfare & Small Arms
    • jschooltigerModerator | Shipbuilding and Logistics | British Navy 1770-1830
    • Elm11Moderator | Winter War
    • CommodoreCoCoModerator | Andean Archaeology
    • WARitterModerator | European Armour and Weapons 1250-1600
    • Snapshot52Moderator | Native American Studies | Colonialism
    • hillsonghoodsModerator | 20th Century Pop Music | History of Psychology
    • ...and 58 more »

    account activity

    1
    1
    2
    3

    ShowcaseSaturday Showcase | April 25, 2026 (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 2 hours ago by AutoModerator - announcement

    • 1 comment
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    2
    5
    6
    7

    SASQShort Answers to Simple Questions | April 22, 2026 (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 3 days ago by AutoModerator - announcement

    • 20 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    3
    85
    86
    87

    In the legend of the Pied Piper, the Mayor and Council refuse to pay him what they owed. In 13th century Germany (the time and place I think the legend is said to take place) what kind of legal remedies would the Piper have had? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 4 hours ago by hisholinessleoxiii

    • 2 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    4
    703
    704
    705

    Why did the Nazis choose to use the Swastika instead of a more Germanically sourced symbol? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 16 hours ago by IndieJones0804

    • 62 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    5
    32
    33
    34

    How did prostitutes and slave women learn to read and write in the Tang dynasty? Are there surviving examples of their poetry? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 4 hours ago by Suippumyrkkyseitikki

    • 4 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    6
    467
    468
    469

    I am a person looking for drugs to do in 19th century Paris, whats popular to party with and how do I go about acquiring them? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 20 hours ago by Motor_Investigator47

    • 36 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    7
    37
    38
    39

    In Terms Of Age, Who Was The Last Recorded Person To See Beethoven Perform/Conduct In His Lifetime? Do We Know? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 10 hours ago by GaiusVelarius

    • 5 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    8
    130
    131
    132

    Was the US House of Representatives frozen at its current size of 435 in 1929 due to fears of immigrants, women, Blacks, socialists, Catholics, and other "undesirables" diluting the power of the white majority? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 17 hours ago by OneMoney6706

    • 9 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    9
    136
    137
    138

    You can't make haggis in the United States because sheep's lung is illegal...why? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 18 hours ago by orwells_elephant

    • 73 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    10
    23
    24
    25

    What do we actually know of Norse and Celtic culture that isn't written by monks centuries after Christianity became the dominant religion of the region? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 9 hours ago by nightterrors644

    • 3 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    11
    11
    12
    13

    Did children/minors ever possess adult slaves ? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 6 hours ago by One_Fix_7094

    • 2 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost

    12
    91
    92
    93

    MetaHow many questions about Nazis do you get disproportionally asked comparative to the rest of history? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 18 hours ago by Dry-Garden-6543

    • 7 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    13
    11
    12
    13

    The Manchus valorised archery skills, but by the time of conquering Mukden (Shenyang), they had access to guns and cannons. What were the Manchu reactions and policies to the usage of the two technologies across the Qing period? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 7 hours ago by Virtual-Alps-2888

    • 2 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost

    14
    15
    16
    17

    During the 17th and early 18th centuries, was there any cross-pollination between pirates of the Caribbean and the corsairs of the North African coast? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 8 hours ago by seidenkaufman

    • 3 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    15
    19
    20
    21

    Before modern streetlights became widespread, what were jobs with the equivalent of a "late-night / midnight shift" like, if there even were any available to begin with? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 10 hours ago by ThatOneBLUScout

    • 2 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    16
    5
    6
    7

    How culturally widespread was divine epiclesis ? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 5 hours ago by HephMelter

    • 2 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    17
    69
    70
    71

    Okay, how bad was the soviet economy really? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 17 hours ago by Shadow_Dragon_1848

    • 27 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    18
    2
    3
    4

    Why upon independence Côte d'Ivoire decided to keep a name heavily associated with European traders? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 2 hours ago by Someone-Somewhere-01

    • 2 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    19
    16
    17
    18

    The Three-Fifths Compromise: 3/5 of a person, or 3/5 of the total population? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 10 hours ago by TechnicalConcern8935

    • 4 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    20
    115
    116
    117

    Why did Jewish communities in Eastern Europe preserve a separate language, but those in Western Europe didn't? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 22 hours ago by MB4050

    • 4 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    21
    467
    468
    469

    We used to say in English say The Ukraine, now we dont. There is also The Lebanon, and The Sudan, but not The Russia or The France. When and why did this convention emerge and change?: (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 1 day ago * by SmellTheJasmine

    • 54 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    22
    •
    •
    •

    How does 1066 compare/contrast with 1532? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted an hour ago by UncleIstvanSaysHello

    • 1 comment
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    23
    5
    6
    7

    Why is cultural and political fragmentation so common in Western history? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted 6 hours ago by Awkward-Scientist-53

    • 4 comments
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    24
    •
    •
    •

    What kind of things did ancient Romans talk about while using shared toilets next to each other? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted an hour ago by Square-Dragonfruit76

    • 1 comment
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...

    25
    •
    •
    •

    To what extent did historical maps of South India (pre-colonial or British Raj) record small, local temples/shrines? Are there highly detailed equivalents to pre-war Japanese topographic maps? (self.AskHistorians)

    submitted an hour ago by solovaris

    • 1 comment
    • share
    • save
    • hide
    • report
    • crosspost
    loading...
    view more: next ›
    • about
    • blog
    • about
    • advertising
    • careers
    • help
    • site rules
    • Reddit help center
    • reddiquette
    • mod guidelines
    • contact us
    • apps & tools
    • Reddit for iPhone
    • Reddit for Android
    • mobile website
    • <3
    • reddit premium

    Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy. © 2026 reddit inc. All rights reserved.

    REDDIT and the ALIEN Logo are registered trademarks of reddit inc.

    Advertise - lifestyles

    Ï€ Rendered by PID 205802 on reddit-service-r2-listing-7d7fbc9b85-z9ps9 at 2026-04-25 15:59:27.528652+00:00 running 2aa0c5b country code: DE.

    Reddit uses cookies and similar technologies to:

    • Keep the website operational and running properly
    • Prevent fraud and abuse
    • Monitor site usage and performance metrics

    Reddit only uses essential cookies on old.reddit.com